Thursday, October 15, 2009

The Jane Austen Reading Group

[In which Audrey takes a look at "old school" reading groups & the art of reading aloud. Enjoy!]

When Jane Austen described her family as “great Novel-readers, & not ashamed of being so,” she was referring, in part, to their habit of reading books aloud as a group. Long before radio or TV became the focus of domestic entertainment, families would assemble to share an agreed-upon title.

These were lively gatherings. After supper or on a rainy afternoon, the stories unfolded, one sentence at a time. The best readers knew how to slow down here, pause there, add an expressive inflection, and give characters their proper voices. Books succeeded or failed on the spot. Every word counts when you’re reading out loud.

Fans of book clubs k
now how much fun it is to talk about literature with other people. Reading an entire work out loud with a friend or in a small group is more time-consuming but infinitely more pleasurable than reading in isolation. Everyone is on the same page. Comments and insights arise in real time.

Henry Austen praised his sister’s reading talents. “She read aloud with very great taste and effect. Her o
wn works, probably, were never heard to so much advantage as from her own mouth; for she partook largely in all the best gifts of the comic muse.” Imagine sitting in on a reading session with the Austen family. Jane opens the book and sizes up her audience. “It is a truth,” she begins, perhaps pausing there, so familiar are her listeners with what comes next. We lean forward in our chairs to catch the arched brow, noticing, as Jane wishes us to, how that word truth can be called into question. Mr. and Mrs. Bennet make their entrance, bickering over their daughters’ futures. They’re right here with us. We can’t wait to hear more.

If Jane were the host of your reading group, she might indulge you in a scene or two from one of her novels. She would prob
ably enjoy being treated like a star since she wasn’t accorded that status in her lifetime; however, she would also introduce you to her sister authors toward whom she felt an enormous allegiance and debt.

She would want you to read Frances Burney and would start
you off with Evelina (1778), the book that launched Burney’s career as the most famous novelist at the end of the 18th century. Jane could deliver comic renditions of dialogue from Evelina that sent her listeners into fits of laughter. Evelina, the ingénue protagonist who doesn’t know the rules of London society, taught Jane a thing or two about putting women at the center of a story, and she would want you to get to know how Burney’s fiction mentored her.

In Jane’s reading group, you would meet Charlotte Lennox’s Female Quixote (1752), the inspiration for Northanger Abbey and Emma. The heroine of this novel, Arabella, is raised in seclusion, and, like the original Quixote, she reads tales of chivalry and confuses them with reality. Arabella thinks that a true hero ought to serve his lady faithfully and perform acts of derring-do in her name for decades before she should even consider giving him her hand. Her fantasies collide comically with the facts of daily life as she struggles to hold her own against the pressures of reality. This book struck such a chord for Austen and her family that they read it no fewer than three times aloud.

Jane would
want you to read Maria Edgeworth’s Belinda (1801), a work that makes clear how hard it is for a young woman to navigate the marriage market without proper guidance and advice. She would recommend Sarah Fielding, Ann Radcliffe, and Elizabeth Inchbald, among others, and perhaps, if she got to know you well enough, she might even suggest that you dip into Mary Wollstonecraft. She could recommend a male writer or two, but she would urge you to pay particular attention to her literary foremothers and sisters, noting that history has not been kind to them, and that they (to paraphrase Virginia Woolf’s argument in A Room of One’s Own) made it possible for her to write.

Shared reading was an important part of the lives of past writers. We know that Jane read sections of her work in progress to family and friends and that she took note of their
responses, with the idea that the novels would be read aloud once published. A niece writes of how Aunt Jane would visit, bringing along her latest manuscript. “She would shut herself up with my elder sisters in one of the bedrooms to read them aloud. I and the younger ones used to hear peals of laughter through the door…” Clearly, Jane liked to make people laugh, and she continues to do so almost two hundred years after her death.

Should you choose to imitate the old-fashioned reading group and gather friends to read aloud, figure that a book the size of Pride and Prejudice will take up six or seven sessions, depending on interruptions, applause, discussion, and digression. Take your time with it, and encourage readers to bring their sections to life and to show off their dramatic skills. One thing that happens when you read out loud is that you end up taking things personally and bringing in your own perspective. “That happened to me,” or “I know someone just like that.” Before you know it, other stories find their way into the room, deepening and enriching relationships, and bringing the book into conversation with the lives of those in the room.

A book is never just a book when you read it out loud. There’s a sense of group ownership and collective experience. One of Jane’s heroines comments, “My idea of good company…is the company of clever, well-informed people, who have a great deal of conversation.” If that’s a view you share, then give the Jane Austen reading group a try. You may never go back to reading alone!

Audrey Bilger © 2007-2009

Pix from Top:
The Travelling Companions: Augustus Leopold Egg
Illustration from the 1833 Bentley edition of Pride & Prejudice
Three-volume early edition of Evelina
Charlotte Lennox
Maria Edgeworth:
Mackenzie, after William Marshall Craig
A Reading:
Thomas Dewing

submit to reddit


  1. What an interesting post. It is years since I read aloud (it must have been when Xan was still young) but I remember it was not easy. When I have occasionally heard authors read from their own works I have been fascinated by the way they read characters who I am familiar with (through reading the books) but they are even more familiar with.

  2. I am sure that these old style reading groups have gone the way of all flesh because the standard of performance will necessarily compare unfavourably with those of the professionals on radio and television. It is a sad fact of modern life, I think, that there is no pace in most people's reckoning for the amateur. Everything has to be of the highest standard. (Maybe the only exceptions are on the net: bloggers and twitters etc!)Congrats on the post, though. More like that, I say!

  3. WT and I read poetry aloud to each other, but I've not read books aloud, since my children were small.

    Tell Audrey I especially enjoyed the visuals included in this post!

  4. I am shocked to realize how ignorant I am of the authors that Audrey mentions in her post. Methinks I have some reading to do. Perhaps we should do an online reading group. We could read to each other via podcast!

  5. A couple of Christmases ago, my husband gave me a collection of 20 cds of the classics read by well-reputed British Actors. This is a Penguin release, in an orange, zippered case and hearing the stories read really brings them to life.
    I do try to read passages of books that I'm reading to my husband and he, likewise will share some of his readings with me. It is such a wonderful way to experience the written word and to share something special between two like-minded individuals. (That sounded a bit stuffy, didn't it?)
    How about this: It's a nice thing to share with a good friend.

  6. Hey everyone!

    I'm so glad you liked this piece. I read out loud to a friend who has vision trouble every Monday, and we talk quite a bit about how reading together is completely different from books on tape/CD or reading to oneself. It's definitely the shared aspect that makes it special. The words go through the voice of the reader and become something two or more people get to experience at the same time. Reading out loud is a bit like the idea of "slow food." Old-fashioned, but worth the effort!

    Willow, John gets all the credit for images on this site. I agree, he does an amazing job of selecting and placing images that enhance the text offerings. He's so very good!

  7. Hi Alan & Dave & Willow & Sandra & Kat & Audrey:

    Wow, you folks have been so great while I was away, & thanks for all your comments!

    Dave: I'm very much with you on the amateur comment.

    Audrey: Thanks to you for the kind words &^ for the great post!


Thanks for stopping by & sharing your thoughts. Please do note, however, that this blog no longer accepts anonymous comments. All comments are moderated. Thanks for your patience.